New Pope Leo XIV Clashes With U.S. Leaders Over Immigration Stance
Pope Leo XIV, formerly Cardinal Robert Prevost, has made his views on immigration unmistakably clear: compassion and dignity must be extended to every person, regardless of their origin. This perspective has placed him at odds with prominent U.S. figures, including Vice President JD Vance and former President Donald Trump.
A Disagreement With JD Vance
Earlier this year, Vice President Vance invoked the Latin phrase ordo amoris—“the order of love”—in a speech emphasizing that Americans should prioritize family and fellow citizens before extending help to outsiders, such as immigrants.
Pope Leo XIV, however, rejected this interpretation. He has consistently argued that love and care cannot be restricted by borders or nationality. According to reporting from The Daily Beast, the future pope even engaged with social media posts countering Vance’s remarks, aligning himself with Pope Francis’s longstanding teaching that Christian love is universal.
Criticism of Trump’s Immigration Policies
Leo XIV’s stance on immigration predates his election to the papacy. During Donald Trump’s presidency, he openly criticized policies that, in his view, treated migrants harshly and ignored the Church’s call to protect the vulnerable. He repeatedly highlighted the moral responsibility to welcome those seeking safety or a better future.
A Papacy Rooted in Compassion
As pope, Leo XIV’s early positions suggest that immigration and human dignity will remain at the forefront of his leadership. His outspoken criticism of restrictive policies—whether from Trump or Vance—underscores his determination to uphold a vision of the Church that champions compassion, inclusion, and care for the marginalized.